Gothamist posted a pretty funny and, frankly, dead-on snippet from The Onion on Thursday citing, "3 million New Yorkers reportedly left the city because they realized the phrase 'Only in New York' is actually just a defense mechanism used to convince themselves that seeing a naked man take a shit on a park bench is somehow endearing, or part of some shared cultural experience." Following this, a long string of comments both accusing the article and praising it–– expected: thus is the nature of the thread–– proceeded into a debate between two women, one with a kid, the other sans. The debate had, at it’s core a debate that’s been happening for a very, very, long time in this here New York City: The immigrants (both international and domestic) versus the born-n’-raised New Yorkers.
This is a debate that will never be resolved, lets face it: there will always be transplants who have a difficult time adjusting to a place that functions just fine without them and there will always be those born within the city’s confines who feel deserved of something from it, from “knowing” it better (do they? Debatable).
Through out this debate, I feel it is important to recognize that this is a city we’re talking about, a place, not a culture. The city is the product of its inhabitants, which are always in a state of flux. Well, is there a culture? Of fucking course there is.
But.
It comes in waves and in temporal movements and this is what fuels the debate: what outlines New York’s culture?
There is no consistency to New York’s traditions other than bagels and pizza–– but oh wait, here come the empanadas and Halal stands. Neighborhoods have complex histories full of such depth neither Bobst or NY Public could hope to contain. Brooklyn is for the most part unrecognizable from what it once was. Little Italy? Eaten by Chinatown.
New York is in a completely perpetual state of transition. We have no idea what it’s going to look like in a few years let alone tomorrow. It’s this uncertainty, this unexpected quality that makes New York what it is. That’s the beauty of New York and (cue the waving American flag in the wind) that’s the beauty of America. We are constructed of immigrants: wise, jaded, been-there-done-that immigrants (or the product there of defending it or rebelling against it) or wide-eyed and brand-spanking new transplants for whom it's really too early to call.
The wise will always be trying to warn and regale the wide-eyed, who should listen because history informs us, but the wise will always forget having ever been wide-eyed.
In other words, everyone is talking but no one is really listening. Commentary.
Commentary.
re: comentary
re: cOmEnTaRy!
re: !!1!com
re: so much comry
re: i know! RIGHT?
You know what?
You shit on that bench, naked man. God bless America.

